GOP Tax Reform Framework and its Impact on International Tax

October 2017

The GOP released the much-awaited instalment of the tax reform guidelines a few days ago, dubbed as the unified framework to overhaul and simplify the Internal Revenue Code. While the framework is high on expectations, the nine-page document is low on details and substance on how to achieve its purported goals.

What’s in it for international business transactions and how does the framework affect the international tax aspect of the US federal income tax system?

20% Corporate Income Tax

The framework calls for a significant reduction in corporation income tax, from the current rate of 35% down to 20%. Decreasing the corporate income tax is a high prerogative for drafters and potentially a game-changer in the manner on how multinational enterprises (MNEs) do business.

Dividends from Foreign Subsidiaries

The framework suggests that dividends from foreign subsidiaries (10% or greater owners) of US corporations will be 100% exempt from US income tax. This aims to encourage MNEs to distribute income earned outside the US.

Repatriation of Foreign Earnings

Foreign earnings accumulated abroad will be subject to a one-time tax. There will be two tax rates – one which is a higher rate for earnings held in cash or cash-equivalents and another lower tax rate for earnings held in other forms of assets over a period of several years. 'How long' we don’t know. When will it be effective? Currently, there is no further information on this point.

Prevention of Profit Shifting

To prevent the shifting of profits to tax havens or low tax jurisdictions, there will be rules made to protect the US tax base. The method suggested is to tax the foreign profits for US MNEs at a reduced rate and on a global basis. Again, there are no details on how this will be implemented but it seems like this will take some form of a 'minimum tax'. Note that the OECD and its member countries have made tremendous strides in advancing its BEPS (Base Erosion and Profit Sharing) guidelines. Are these pronouncements an implied capitulation to OECD’s BEPS? Is the US finally aligning with OECD?

Levelling the Playing Field for US Inbound Companies

In tune with the administration’s nationalistic tone, the framework wants to provide rules that will level the playing field between homegrown US companies and foreign companies doing business in the US. The execution of this plan is still unclear but it looks like this is something along the lines of strengthening the thin capitalisation rules under Sec. 163(j) and Sec. 385 aimed at protecting the stripping of taxable income subject to US taxation.

Observations

It is worth noting that in a span of less than 12 months the GOP went from the obscure Destination-Based Cash Flow Taxation (DBCFT) proposal to this new-look tax framework. Will these new ideas stick? For sure, questions are beginning to surface. What will be the impact on the 68 bilateral income tax treaties the US signed with other countries? Will they be rewritten? What about the Section 482 rules? Since there will be no incentive to park profits abroad, will transfer pricing go away?

The new framework is certainly a step in the right direction and should encourage companies to re-engage in this dialogue. While history seems to suggest that tax reform is a messy and cumbersome process, it is not too late to start discussion with your tax advisors to plan ahead.

How BlumShapiro can help

To effectively navigate the complex international tax laws, BlumShapiro offers clients a broad range of international tax strategies. Our member firm helps their clients to understand and meet their tax compliance obligations. More importantly, the firm helps them to identify and reduce their tax risks and implement practical and efficient tax strategies that will meet their needs today into the future.

Contact

Further information about this can be obtained by contacting William Inchoco